Can It Happen Here?
An email from the founder of the Jewish Institute for Liberal Values
Over the weekend, I received an email from a reader responding to my most recent conversation with John McWhorter, in which we discussed antisemitism at length. Given the history of antisemitism, when one contemplates its emergence in force within a society, the mind goes to terrible places: mass expulsions, pogroms, the Holocaust, and so on.
But, as David Bernstein points out, there are less dramatic ways that antisemitism can repress Jews and Jewish life without rising to the level of attempted genocide. In David’s email, which I submit below with his permission, he suggests that the “woke left,” while not antisemitic by definition, is more hospitable to antisemitism than its purported commitment to “diversity” might lead one to expect. I thank David for his thoughtful comments and look forward to reading yours.
This post is free and available to the public. To receive early access to TGS episodes, an ad-free podcast feed, Q&As, and other exclusive content and benefits, click below.
Glenn and John,
Thank you for your recent discussion on antisemitism on The Glenn Show. I am a long time Jewish professional leader and the immediate past CEO of the umbrella organization overseeing mainstream Jewish advocacy organizations across the country. I left nearly two years ago amid the growth of woke ideology in mainstream Jewish life and started a new organization called the Jewish Institute for Liberal Values devoted to viewpoint diversity in the Jewish world. I’m also the author of the recently released Woke Antisemitism: How a Progressive Ideology Harms Jews.
I thought John gave a perfectly well-reasoned critique of the overblown response to Kanye’s cartoonish behavior. I do think John got it wrong, however, when he suggested that Jewish sensitivity to antisemitism is primarily animated by the trepidation that “it could happen here.” I happen to agree that it’s very unlikely that growing antisemitism in America will culminate in another Holocaust. But there are many dystopian scenarios well short of genocide.
The white nationalist variant of antisemitism has already resulted in distortions to Jewish life. Jews can no longer safely go to synagogue without an elaborate set of security arrangements. This threat has added tens of millions of dollars annually to Jewish organizational budgets (causing already financially stretched Jewish organizations to go belly up) and is further exacerbated by the threat emanating from radical Muslims against American Jewish institutions (Jewish organizations get regular briefings from the FBI and Homeland Security about threats of terrorism emanating from the Middle East). Imagine if the number of domestic shootings triples in the next few years. Such an outcome would render Jewish life unlivable for many Jews.
When you combine the threat from the white nationalist right with the growing ideological antisemitism on the left, it’s understandable why many Jews—even the less hysterical among us—are beginning to feel besieged. Woke ideology is the perfect accelerant of antisemitism on the left, as it neatly divides the world into oppressed and oppressor and conflates success with oppression. The concern about the left is less about violence against Jews than it is political disenfranchisement. ADL CEO Jonathan Greenblatt aptly compared antisemitism on the right to a hurricane and antisemitism on the left to climate change (he fails, however, to identify the “CO2 emissions” on the left—woke ideology—producing the change in climate).
Take a look at this report about rising antisemitism at the University of Toronto medical school. I spoke to a progressive Jewish law professor at the same university last week who feels he now works in a hostile environment. This may not be happening everywhere to the same degree, but it is happening in more places, more often. It could be a precursor of things to come in growing swaths of the US.
Another result of wokeness is declining American support for Israel (see our recent poll). Granted, deteriorating fealty to the Jewish State does not by itself constitute antisemitism. But the corrosion of support for Israel certainly impacts the sense of place of many liberal Zionist Jews in the Democratic Party and, by extension, in the broader society. Along with this diminution in support comes growing anti-Zionism and grotesque characterizations of Israel as a “settler-colonialist state.” I agree with Glenn that anti-Zionism is not ipso facto antisemitism, but it often does come packaged with demonization of Jews and the Jewish state. While I don’t think that the Democratic Party is on the precipice of “Corbynization” (becoming like Jeremy Corbyn’s hostile Labour Party in the UK), who knows what another ten years of this untamed ideology might bring?
Last but not least, the biggest fear of Jews and others ought to be the undermining of liberalism and the sense-making institutions in American life coming from both ends of the ideological spectrum, further polarizing our already polarized society. I can imagine it getting much worse. Such a dystopia would affect everyone, but surely Jews will feel it earlier and more acutely than most, and who knows what atrocities might come about in the chaos?
Anyway, I enjoy and learn from your discussions. I believe I will be seeing you at a convening in London in a few weeks. Many thanks.
David Bernstein
Founder, Jewish Institute for Liberal Values
I agree with this and admire David Bernstein and the Jewish Institute for Liberal Values in just about every particular. However, I am not so sure about the statement that, "deteriorating fealty to the Jewish State does not by itself constitute antisemitism."
No, I suppose it does not in many specific cases, but Israel is central, not peripheral, to the forms real antisemitism takes now, especially on the left. Israel was the most important Jewish response to the Holocaust (as opposed to an embrace of perpetual victimhood). The best way to ensure "never again" was and is the IDF, not maudlin handwringing about image after image of emaciated Jews in the camps. The Jew as strong, not weak, was the response, a correct response.
But it is precisely that which the left with its BDS campaigns, it's "river to the sea" chants, its intimidation of Jews on many campuses (regardless of their views about Israel), is angry about. The audacity of Jews standing up and demanding the world's acceptance on their terms, not the world's. When Ilhan Omar said "Israel hypnotizes the world, Allah protect us against Israel," she was not making a statement about specific Israeli governmental policies. She was translating an ages-old story about Jews as all-powerful deceivers and parasites, the standard trope used time and time again (about Jews as insidious powers behind the throne). Israel takes the place of Jews in this tapestry of contempt. Hence it is Israel that Jews MUST defend now as absolutely essential to the preservation of their existence as a people.
LOL the compassionate left was going to deny hospital beds to people that would not get vaccinated during covid. The Canadian government was canceling people's bank accounts and our own Society ostracized people including firing them from the workplace for not doing as they were told. Only a complete moron doesn't see the parallels with the holocaust... wagging your finger at the past while at the same time not looking in the mirror has become a national pastime...