Discussion about this post

User's avatar
George H's avatar

I am amazed that John seems to have some sympathy for the removal of a statue of Christopher Columbus, because he thinks, to some extent, that Columbus may have been motivated by the desire to make money and wasn’t a good person. My goodness, Columbus led the group that discovered the new world! An event that shaped and continues to shape our world in profound ways with both great positive and negative effect. He is a figure of immense historical importance. How is it that he can even consider canceling Christopher Columbus, and to make room for what? What narrative does he think will replace it when the statue is removed? What do we elevate to take its place, a memorialization of 1619?

How should we weigh the importance of John’s concerns against the monumental role Columbus has played in world history? Relegate his statue to a museum? It’s a shame some people are triggered by the statue and therefore seem willing to downplay the role he has played in our consciousness, by removing his statue. But, there are a great many things we can learn from the story of Christopher Columbus, and his role in how we got to be where we are today as a nation, and as a civilization. There are positives and negatives. I’m sorry people get triggered. I take it that John is truly disturbed, I would say triggered, by some aspects of the Christopher Columbus story, but the story needs telling. The good and the bad. For those who are concerned that the statues venerate, let them denigrate. Statues in prominent places remind us of our history. So, let those who focus on the negative tell that story when they see the statue, and those who see another picture tell that story, but the stories need to be told. They need to be called to our attention. They need discussing. Erasing statues is intended to remove the stories. In this case of our history, important history. Let’s not let that happen.

Expand full comment
Lhfry's avatar

Thank you for taking this on. Unfortunately many young people - products of universities in recent decades - know so little history that they may be unable to even discuss your points.

Expand full comment
36 more comments...

No posts