Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Frederick Hotchner's avatar

Yan Shen said, "I don't feel like white Americans these days have much appetite for defending meritocracy anymore." I recently read Shelby Steele's book, WHITE GUILT. I wish I had read it back when he wrote it, as it explained so much. His basic thesis (in my words, and no doubt I won't do it justice) is that white people carried guilt from the period of our history before 1964 and that that guilt has ever since undermined any moral authority we might like to claim we have. Add to that the current zeitgeist, in which a white person taking exception to the assertions of what I'll call the critical left will result in charges of racism, transphobia, etc., and too many whites have decided to keep their heads down and hope this storm blows over. I, too, have noticed the seemingly disproportionate number of Asian-Americans who are stepping into the breach to defend meritocracy and take other important stands, and I greatly appreciate it. I hope more white people will find the self-confidence and summon up the courage to engage.

Expand full comment
Mark Silbert's avatar

George and Yan Shen, thanks for your interesting emails.

George, while it might be understandable that many Chinese Americans look to the emergence of modern day China with pride this needs to be tempered by the recognition of just what kind of society and nation it has become. China today is a communist dictatorship run by the CCP and its' autocratic Chairman Xi Jinping. They perpetuate genocide, massive inequality and a meritocracy for Party members and their families but excludes everyone else. There is no such thing as a recall election in China and any attempt to try to secure fair admissions standards for the children of non CCP members would be met with derision if not outright violence. I applaud the contributions made by Chinese Americans and I believe it is largely due to the Chinese values of hard work, education, merit, familial responsibility, patience, adaptability and self respect.

Expand full comment
26 more comments...

No posts