Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Substack Reader's avatar

I'll get excited about climate change when people are marching in the streets, demanding nuclear power plants be built as quickly as possible. When we have an Operation Warp Speed for nuclear power plants.

After 50 years, last year the Dems finally removed opposition to nuclear from their party platform. About time, eh? And AOC's early release of her Green New Deal specifically banned nuclear. These people are not serious about climate change.

Expand full comment
Images of Broken Light's avatar

I don't think it's capitalism, but rather technology, that has changed things so much. And technology is an extension of the growth of human knowledge through science, which ultimately is simply an expression of human intelligence -- this is what intelligence does. Blaming a political or economic philosophy is missing the point.

Furthermore, we really don't have a choice about this. If the knowledge exists to make certain technologies possible, someone will invent it, and they, and their society, will reap the near-term economic benefits of having developed it. If you decide that you're not going to do that because it would (or might) be bad for the world in some way, then the benefits will be someone else's, but the technology will still exist.

I don't think there's an example in history of a society that failed to develop some technology that was possible at the time, and continued to be successful in the long term unless they were simply isolated from the rest of the world -- and eventually that just makes the problem worse, because isolation may last for centuries or millennia but it won't last forever.

Now, of course, as we know now, technology often has nasty side-effects that can cause serious problems in the long term. I'm not suggesting otherwise. Anthropogenic climate change and microplastic pollution are only two examples. The thing is, though, abandoning technology, or refusing to develop it, is not a viable solution. The big problem is that there may not be a viable solution.

Expand full comment
14 more comments...

No posts