202 Comments
⭠ Return to thread

"...actual Black people ..."What disqualifies either Loury or McWhorter from being genuinely black? It seems to me that you are proving their point. You are substituting your perceptions for objective reality.

Expand full comment

Coons go in their own category. But please do share your "objective reality" definition of genuine Black.

Expand full comment

Black Conservatives give as good as they get. They said Black Democrats lived on a plantation. They cannot be surprised that we laugh as they have to fall in line to remain in the good graces of the GOP.

Google Alan Keyes and what he says about Black Democrats. Most Black voters feel zero sympathy for Black Republicans. Black Democrats have the example of Fannie Lou Hamer. Black Republicans who do not bend the knee are kicked out of the party.

In “Woke Racism” a comparison is made between Liberals and a species of grasshopper who drown themselves after being infected by a brain worm. Don’t believe for a minute that Black Democrats have not been personally attacked.

Black voters see no reason to connect with Charles Murray, Heather MacDonald, and Amy Wax. Why would we want to be in the same party as such creatures?

I believe that Loury and McWhorter admit that the majority of Black students disagree with many of their statements. A Coleman Hughes is an outlier.

Expand full comment

One of the few advantages of being older than dirt is that I know history did not begin in the last five years. I watched racist President LBJ approach the self-anointed civil rights leaders and promise them both riches and a seat at the table if they would just tell their followers that the true measure of how much a political party is on their side is the amount of money devoted to social programs. And nobody paid attention to the Moynihan Report.

Expand full comment

Typical Conservative response, “Look over here”

Racist LBJ got Civil Rights bills passed

Democrats lost white Southern voters

The Congressional vote was a South vs North vote

Democrats were a Southern party

Few Southern Democrats voted for the bills

No Southern Republican voted for the Civil Rights bill

Current Republican legislators and judges peel away the Civil Rights Act

They also work to suppress Black votes

Now you come shouting “But, but, but …….. Moynihan

Conservatives are not serious people when it comes to solving racial issues.

It is an appropriate time to mention that a Conservative here said poverty improved under Trump. That is a lie. Poverty increased dramatically under Trump.

https://thehill.com/opinion/finance/535239-how-trump-fueled-economic-inequality-in-america/

It is painful to talk to Conservatives because they are masters of distraction. The major benefit of the discussions is that it reinforces why you believe what you believe. Conservatives have no viable message.

Expand full comment

You appear to be under the mistaken impression that I am a conservative. My first vote for President was for George McGovern; my politics have not changed. I marched in Civil Rights protests and joined sit-ins.

Moynihan was without doubt the greatest liberal thinker of the 20th Century.

You've made a number of assertions which, I suppose, I should believe because you've stated them.

Expand full comment

I’m not asking you to believe anything. You started off with racist President LBJ. LBJ got the Civil Rights bills passed. If you start off with racist LBJ and follow it with “self-annointed leaders” (MLK?), what other impression I am supposed to have?

Expand full comment

I don't care what impression you have. LBJ was openly racist; the Civil Rights legislation was passed with Republican votes. Jesse Jackson, Al Sharpton, James Farmer, Ella Baler. John Lewis were all self-anointed leaders.

Expand full comment