6 Comments
User's avatar
Ted's avatar

Whenever I contemplate the category errors applied to individuals during discriminatory selection processes, I reflect on Caplan's theory of irrationality.

There is also the practical matter of selection criteria; inclusion within a hierarchy will be dependent on an appraisal of willingness to subordinate. This is not a trivial factor. Absent direct and open coercion, a particular array of circumstance selects.

Expand full comment
geoffrey faust's avatar

One benefit of humility is the avoidance of the hubris that motivates totalizing narratives, and worse, totalizing Utopian programs of action. One example would be the progressive vision for America.

It would be better to recognize that the story is always going to be incomplete, thus leaving some things to be created and discovered by the humans who will live after us.

Expand full comment
Jamal X's avatar

For clarification, what is [your perspective] on the progressive vision for America? Your conservative vision? What do you want to conserve?

Expand full comment
Thomas DeGruccio's avatar

Thrust and parry, Monty, kudos! I wish to conserve the greatest experiment in humanity!

Expand full comment
Thomas DeGruccio's avatar

I almost gagged when Rohini referred to diversity of opinion in academia. It doesn’t exist. Look elsewhere to acquire ( not simply inherit)the intellectual wherewithal to achieve your goals.

Expand full comment
Steve's avatar

"Read widely and deeply.'

Memo to EVERYONE!

Expand full comment