Thanks. Study was done in 2011 with 33 subjects. The results have not changed what experts say currently about IQs not changing much after kindergarten. This appears to be the only study of its kind.
Thanks. Study was done in 2011 with 33 subjects. The results have not changed what experts say currently about IQs not changing much after kindergarten. This appears to be the only study of its kind.
You don't but experts in the field do. It's not my field of expertise but I would tend to go with what experts say. The study was never replicated, it's a total of 33 children, I know nothing technically about the fMRI that was used or the settings. It was 20% of the subjects that gained or lost IQ points- that's 7 subjects. Half lost points- perhaps due to sports/brain injuries. That leaves 3 or 4 that gained points. That's not a lot of evidence to base much on.
So, if a study is small about fluctuations in IQ in teenaged kids, then IQ is set at five? All I can find says at least IQ stabilizes at puberty. Saying “experts say” doesn’t mean much. I’ve read a lot about brain development in kids and I have never read that. Also, if you have ever hung out with kids, all things develop in spurts, at different rates in different kids. There is the whole idea of a “late bloomer” and the notion that precocious kids are not necessarily geniuses for a reason.
Thanks. Study was done in 2011 with 33 subjects. The results have not changed what experts say currently about IQs not changing much after kindergarten. This appears to be the only study of its kind.
I don’t see anything to support that IQ is set by age 5. Do you actually have any evidence? It seems completely absurd to me.
You don't but experts in the field do. It's not my field of expertise but I would tend to go with what experts say. The study was never replicated, it's a total of 33 children, I know nothing technically about the fMRI that was used or the settings. It was 20% of the subjects that gained or lost IQ points- that's 7 subjects. Half lost points- perhaps due to sports/brain injuries. That leaves 3 or 4 that gained points. That's not a lot of evidence to base much on.
So, if a study is small about fluctuations in IQ in teenaged kids, then IQ is set at five? All I can find says at least IQ stabilizes at puberty. Saying “experts say” doesn’t mean much. I’ve read a lot about brain development in kids and I have never read that. Also, if you have ever hung out with kids, all things develop in spurts, at different rates in different kids. There is the whole idea of a “late bloomer” and the notion that precocious kids are not necessarily geniuses for a reason.
I only hung out with kids when I was a kid. I am not all that interested in this subject to continue this conversation.